John Mayer has just about run out of girls to hit on in L.A. He was scraping the bottom of the barrel this past weekend New York hotspot Butter where he was seen getting cooties from Lindsay Lohan.

Lindsay and John were not only seen dancing in the nightclub, but sharing a table together as well. Although sources say that he was as not into her as she was him…he still kept coming back to their shared table all night long.

Lindsay followed The Playa around all night like a puppy dog while he downed shots of vodka. He must not have minded the attention too much, they stayed until 3am.

“She would follow his every move,” the source says. “He would dance with the waitresses and then come back. She was way into it.”

And or course Lilo took immediately to twitter to share her experience writing to John, “shhhhhhhhhhhhhh butter-face :) .”

lindsay-john-mayer